View Message

[Opinions] Elinor
I've always loved the name, and especially this spelling. It just seems much classier to me. However, recent comments have made me begin to doubt myself. I'm afraid that the most Americans are unfamiliar with this spelling, and would see it as a trendy alternative to the spelling of Eleanor. What do you guys think?It's not too high on my list, so it's not much of a problem. However, I do adore the nicknames Nell and Nelly, so it might get higher. TIA.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I like Elinor a lot, though I would choose Eleanor my self. And I don't really think ELeanor is a name that people would assume you changed the spelling of, as it isn't the typical style of name that people feel the need to spell different.Also Nelly is adorable.
vote up1
There is a possiblity some will see it as a kre8tyv spelling of Eleanor, but I'm not really concerned with those people's opinions (they haven't read "Sense & Sensibility" after all, lol). Nora is my favorite nn, but I prefer it as a name on it's own. I also like Ella, Ellie, and Nell, but I see Nellie/Nelly in a negative light (for a couple of different reasons) so it's not a favorite. Eleanor and Elinor are actually neck-and-neck for me but I'm very traditional when it comes to name-spelling so I'd probably go with Eleanor. ;)
vote up1
I prefer Eleanor, but there's nothing wrong with Elinor. It doesn't look trendy to me. Now, Ellynor, that would be trendy.
vote up1
I actually prefer Elinor & Elanor to Eleanor. I think even if people aren't familiar with the Elinor spelling, they should still be able to prn the name properly, regardless. And most people really don't care whether it's a trendy spelling or not...I think it's just us. :o)
vote up1
I like both spellings, but I don't think most Americans would be unfamiliar. I'm American and I've seen that spelling just as often if not more often in fact. Although I'm not a normal American... :)
vote up1
I much prefer Elinor to EleanorIt just looks nicer to me. I would have thought that most people would be at least aware of the existence of Elinor as a legit name, so I doubt there'd be problems :)
vote up1
I don't think it matters what most people think. It is a classic name, and anyone familiar with Jane Austen will appreciate the spelling! I prefer Eleanor myself (Elinor seems too clipped and casual to me...I see Eleanor as being more classy and 'full'), but both are nice spellings of a beautiful name.
vote up1
Ditto everything.
vote up1