View Message

[Opinions] Shawn and Shawna
I was going to post a comment about Nastia and Shawn after last nights exciting competition, but as someone else already posted about Nastia I will just comment on Shawn.What do you think of Shawn on a girl? Personally I adore it. I don't think it looks at all silly used on Shawn Johnson. I knew a girl called Shawna once and I always disliked the a at the end of her name. It seemed redundant and I used to wonder why her parents had not used Shawn instead. It works just as well to me.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I think Shawn/Sean is entirely masculine without taking into consideration it's my brother's best friend's name (a guy) and I know a guy named Sean Johnson. Shawna doesn't do much for me either. I just like Sean and only on guys.
vote up1
Thing is, I have a non-rhotic accent and Shawn (to me) sounds exactly like shorn. IDK Shawn looks really funny anyway. Shaun or Sean are much better, and as Bear has already said Sian (Shaahn) is ten times better than all of them for a girl.
vote up1
I think Shawn on a girl is ridiculous. Just put the darn -a on it. It makes it a girl's name then and sounds so much nicer on a girl. Shawn is a boy's name.I like Sean on a boy, and kind of like Shawna on a girl. Those are my favorite spellings of each.
vote up1
I know a Shawn. Unfortunately she's not a very nice girl. Occasionally, rude people would ask her why she has a boy's name. Kids in her elementary school I'm sure all thought of this, but kept the question to themselves. She was just Shawn. But when she went to junior high, people were much more confused. I think suspect they started becoming much more open-minded by highschool though. But really her name always struck me as being slightly too masculine. I don't mind Shawna. I met the sweetest girl with this name. But her brother was named Shawn...now I think that's a little ridiculous.
vote up1
From what I have read on the subject I think children develop like that. I think in elementary school, at that age, children just accept things as they are much more. So if a girl is called Shawn, then they just accept it, unless someone, someone older maybe, draws attention to it. Even then, I think the children forget about it again more quickly. As children get older, I think they look at similarities and differences and also gender distinctions. So yes, again, I think middle school might be a time when most attention gets drawn to it. Both girls and boys emphasizing it is different. At high school, children are more mature of course and also children are more into developing personal identities and become a bit more confident in themselves. I imagine there, if she is comfortable with her name, then it could be a plus at that age with the individuality and uniqueness of it. Good points.I agree with you about Shawna and Shawn. That makes me cringe at the thought of it.
vote up1
Look like tacky names for twins. I get annoyed when twins have practically the same names.
vote up1
like Brandon and Brenda on Beverly Hills 90210 (TV series) ugh
vote up1
Normally I really dislike gender-bender names, but Shawn (along with Billie) seems to work quite well on a girl. I'm not sure why, but they do. I know a Shana prn SHAW-nuh. It suits her.
vote up1
I know a woman names Shaun who despises her name. She hated having a boy's name her whole life and still does. I would personally hate to have a boy's name too and would never name my daughter one!
vote up1
I love Sian for a girl. It's a traditional Welsh girl's name. But here's the trick. I've heard it pronounced "shawn," just like the Irish male name Sean. But one or two people here on the boards swear it's supposed to be pronounced "shann." I've never been able to get a Welsh person to tell me the true pronunciation. For now, I'm sticking with the "shawn" one.I dislike the "Shawn" spelling for either gender.

This message was edited 8/15/2008, 11:53 AM

vote up1
Sian is not pronounced the same as Sean! At least, I've never heard it that way over here.Sian is with a long ah sound like the word Shah with an "n" on the end. Sian is fairly common in Britain (especially Wales) and there are some well known people like the weather presenter Sian Lloyd and the BBC newsreader Sian Williams.I agree it's pretty. And I also dislike the name Shawn.
vote up1
Sian is with a long ah sound like the word Shah with an "n" on the end.Lol, that's how I pronounce Shawn, though! Maybe it's just my lazy US accent. ;) There's no actual "W" sound when I say Shawn, it's just kind of slurred together for me.
vote up1
Me too!I was wondering how else to say Sean other than, "shahn."I'm glad someone from the UK has let me know how Sian is pronounced. But how Rose-Berry pronounces Sean now intrigues me.
vote up1
I have seen Sian before but have no idea how to say it and have never met anyone of that name. I used to say it as Sigh-Ann until someone corrected me that that was totally wrong! I think it is pretty though.
vote up1
I have a cousin named Sian, and she pronounces it Sigh-ann. I thought her name was Cyan at first...but then, she isn't Welsh.
vote up1
Some Gaelic helpA lot of us here have gotten pretty good at Gaelic pronunciation, though we (for the most part) can't speak it. The combination "si" makes an "sh" sound. An "is" also often makes an "sh" sound. "Bh" makes a soft "v" sound. Therefore, the names Siobhan and Aisling would be pronounced shi-VAHN and ASH-ling. The letter "e" is often pronounced "uh" when at the end of names (Aoife = EE-fuh). Now, I'm no expert, so anybody here who can actually speak Gaelic is welcome to correct me, but I think those are pretty basic rules that I picked up from years of looking at the names.
vote up1
Thanks againThank you again Aileen. You are giving me a great education in pronouncing words today. I love to learn new things so I really appreciate it. I especially like the Aoife pronunciation. I had no idea how to say that and I think it would be very embarrassing if I told you how I said it :)
vote up1
Believe me, I was clueless when I came tooI used to really love Irish names (I still like them, but my style is more Eastern European now), and when I just started spending a lot of time on BtN I researched a lot of Irish names. When I discovered Caoilfhionn I was horrified. Seriously, the name looks nuts! But you'd never believe that it's simply pronounced "KEE-lin", which is really quite nice. You get used to it after a while. Mind, I've been here forever, but eventually wild-looking names won't be such a shock to you because you will recognize some etymological roots within the names.
vote up1
SianI think Sian is pronounced "Shaaahn" with a long ahhhh sound whether Shawn is "Shawn" with an awwww sound (if that makes any sense). so they sound pretty much alike but not exactly the same.
vote up1
I agree with Lily, when I think of Shawn Johnson I don't have a problem with the name. But before I knew who Shawn Johnson was, I thought it was very ugly for a girl. Bottom line though, I wouldn't use it for a girl.I don't like Shawna at all, I don't think the 'a' makes it any less masculine.

This message was edited 8/15/2008, 11:24 AM

vote up1
Honestly as much as I love boys names on girls, and girls names on boys, etc. This one I don't seem to wrap around. My friend also likes the name Shawn on a girl. I think it could work on a girl I know a Shawna and I thought that was nice.I think it's because I don't care for Shawn on a boy either, lol. I think if you like a name then use it though. I've seen Shawn on a girl a few times.
vote up1
Do you really like boys names on girls and vice versa? Wow! Me too! Well, I find it fascinating and I like it too. I really like gender ambiguous names and then names that defy gender or the use of names that defy gender. I also like balancing names of each gender, sort of like balancing the masculine and feminine, ying and yang. Maybe that's weird to some people, but I love playing with masculine-feminine and feminine-masculine combos that can work for each gender.
vote up1
I absoutely love it [m]I love love love it so much. It's fun I honestly don't think of gender when I look at names unless it's really obvious. I like balancing them out too.I personally consider all nature/word/place names things that don't have a gender as unisex by default :).What names do you like?
vote up1
Wow! I don't really see gender when I look at a name either. Not at first anyway. Interesting ideas about nature/word/place names. I have to think about that, but I probably agree. I think I would add to that adjectives too, unless you consider those as words.The names I like are really really long! I'll have to make a list and share it. But for me it's the combinations and the feelings I get from the name, the combination and the actual person. For fun I like to play with names, but I almost can't imagine naming my baby before seeing it. Does that make sense?
vote up1
Yes :)
vote up1
I like Shawn Johnson and when I think of her the name is really cute. But when I don't think of her I think it's a really ugly very very masculine name. I agree with you about Shawna. Shawna is probably one of the names I dislike most in the world (no offense). I just hate the sound. Shawn is way better than Shawna.Hmmm yeah Shawn is better than Shawna and not a bad name but I think with all the pretty girls names out there you can find a better one than Shawn.I also think a girl named Shawn would have it really difficult in life because people would always assume she was a boy. I think Shawn Johnson's middle name is Machel. I wonder how they pronounce it. Does anyone happen to know ? I hope hope hope hope it's not a silly spelling of Michelle.

This message was edited 8/15/2008, 1:12 PM

vote up1
Hi Lily. Thanks for your comments. I didn't know about her middle name being Machel. That is an unusual one. I wonder how it is pronounced. I wonder if it is like Michelle too, but should it not have an -elle ending? As it is, it almost looks like Michael/Michal ? Shawn Michael would definitely suggest a boy combo of course. I don't know if Shawn Johnson has ever had people wonder about her being a boy. Maybe her manner and cuteness just make the name cute for her, but I like it on other girls too.
vote up1
yeah at first I thought it was Michal but I'm pretty sure it's supposed to be Michelle or Mah-KELL ? must be really confusing. I actually prefer Shawn on a girl (really dislike it on a boy, just like Shawna on a girl) but I'd choose a really feminine middle name if I had to use it.
vote up1
I know a female Shawn. To me it's the same as Alexis and Alexia. Whichever you like, you use.
Nastia (or Nastya) is the nickname for Anastasia.
vote up1
Hi Jennifer. Good point. With Alexis and Alexia though you are at least changing a letter. With Shawna you just add one. I agree though that it is personal taste. If you like it, use it.
vote up1