New Post
Search
Help[Opinions] It is?
in reply to a message by Caemlyn
I've never in my life heard toll-KEEN. Where did you find out it was the right one?
What I have always said was TOLL-keen.
What I have always said was TOLL-keen.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1
Replies
My husband's professor was a friend of the family
Unfortunately, he retired before we were able to take his lit course on Tolkien. I was really looking forward to it :(
Unfortunately, he retired before we were able to take his lit course on Tolkien. I was really looking forward to it :(
1
Hmm, no . . .
I've had a long chat with a guy who WAS a close personal friend of Tolkien himself, and who grew up in the same area, and he pronounced it TOL-kən like pretty much everyone else in the world.
So I totally disagree with tol-KEEN
I've had a long chat with a guy who WAS a close personal friend of Tolkien himself, and who grew up in the same area, and he pronounced it TOL-kən like pretty much everyone else in the world.
So I totally disagree with tol-KEEN
1
Hmmm...Yes (edit)
Did he use that prn. as an adult? I've known more than a couple people who, for one reason or another, chose a different prn. as an adult.
And, by "he" do you mean this guy you talked to, or J.R.R. and his family?
AND, is this the way the family prn. it, or the way "people" and "the world" pronounce it, because many people know us, but still pronounce our last name incorrectly.
ETA:
http://www.tolkiensociety.org/tolkien/biography.html
Did he use that prn. as an adult? I've known more than a couple people who, for one reason or another, chose a different prn. as an adult.
And, by "he" do you mean this guy you talked to, or J.R.R. and his family?
AND, is this the way the family prn. it, or the way "people" and "the world" pronounce it, because many people know us, but still pronounce our last name incorrectly.
ETA:
http://www.tolkiensociety.org/tolkien/biography.html
This message was edited 8/23/2008, 2:39 PM
1
Still not convinced, sorry - my evidence is more direct than yours.
1
How?
You talked to a guy who was a friend of the family. I knew I guy who was a friend of the family. Seems pretty even to me.
You talked to a guy who was a friend of the family. I knew I guy who was a friend of the family. Seems pretty even to me.
1
I'm watching..
a documentary about Tolkien right now and they are saying 'TOL-keen', I'm pretty certain that's right. I have never even heard 'tol-KEEN' before.
a documentary about Tolkien right now and they are saying 'TOL-keen', I'm pretty certain that's right. I have never even heard 'tol-KEEN' before.
This message was edited 8/22/2008, 10:02 AM
1