New Post
Search
Help[Facts] This is my last reply to you
in reply to a message by cute_boy85@hotmail.fr
Nobody said that Amazigh (in the variant Tarifit or in general) is Arabic. So, read correctly the posts before to reply and don't put words in other mouths.
For the questions about Arabic vowels (sound) plus Arabic vowels marks (spelling) and dialects, I stated very clearly in my other posts and you can check its accuracy in some reliable basical books, as Modern Arabic: Structures, Functions and Varieties, by Clive Holes, or Elementary Modern Standard Arabic, by Peter F. Abboud et al.
I would like to see academical and bibliographical proof of all your affirmations.
My former student (and his family) is born in Al-hoceima, not an Arabic immigrant to the city or the area.
Sentences like "all what you said is BS" or "you know nothing you just bla bla bla" are absolutely rude and rudeness is not welcome when discussing in this board.
Lumia
http://onomastica.mailcatala.com
For the questions about Arabic vowels (sound) plus Arabic vowels marks (spelling) and dialects, I stated very clearly in my other posts and you can check its accuracy in some reliable basical books, as Modern Arabic: Structures, Functions and Varieties, by Clive Holes, or Elementary Modern Standard Arabic, by Peter F. Abboud et al.
I would like to see academical and bibliographical proof of all your affirmations.
My former student (and his family) is born in Al-hoceima, not an Arabic immigrant to the city or the area.
Sentences like "all what you said is BS" or "you know nothing you just bla bla bla" are absolutely rude and rudeness is not welcome when discussing in this board.
Lumia
http://onomastica.mailcatala.com
This message was edited 6/3/2010, 10:03 AM
1