I like both and it would depend what I pair them with and what my fam name would wind up being and which dh prefers...
Carmen Chantel is kinda pretty...
Carmen Shihiro and Michina
Carmel are on my long list.
I think
Carmel works esp. well as a mn.
Choose which side of these either belongs on... and whether
Carmen or
Carmel works better w/ it:
JanelleJoelleEstelleEstellaRoshika
EstherMelanieMelodyJocelynJasmineAmaryllisBrielleGabriellaElizabethElisaEliseAmandaVanessaJanessaMichelleNoelleNoellaRoselleRosellaJacinta