View Message

[Opinions] Arthur or Basil?
Which would you choose, given the two choices?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Arthur!It's always been a sweet, warm name to me. Basil sounds hideous to me, unfortunately.
vote up1
BasilI want to like Arthur. I really do. It's just the sort of old fashioned, mythology type name that I usually go for. But I've never been able to really take it to heart. I'd love to meet a little Arthur one day. I love seeing any old fashioned name revived. But when you put it next to a darling like Basil the choice is clear.I love the sound of razzle-dazzle-Basil. And the Fawlty Towers character only adds to the love.
vote up1
ArthurArthur is my second favorite male name, but I love Basil as well.
vote up1
Arthur, because it is strong and knightly whereas Basil is quirky and British.
vote up1
Definitely Basil. It's dashing. While I can appreciate Arthur's sophistication and dignity, I'm not too keen on the sound of the name.
vote up1
ArthurBecause it's a family name. But Basil is good too.
vote up1
Arthur!
vote up1
Arthur
vote up1
ArthurPeople would not know how to pronounce Basil, I'd worry. And I think Basil seems stuffy, and that seems worse than the whininess I get from Arthur. At least Arthur brings chivalry to mind. Basil just makes me think of middle aged dorky wimpy guys. Fawlty Towers, I guess. Not enough exposure.

This message was edited 2/29/2012, 10:00 PM

vote up1
Arthur, any day of the week. After all, Basil shortens to Baz!
vote up1
Basil!Or even better, Basile :)Arthur is too stodgy for me
vote up1
Immediately, I thought, "Arthur!" Then I considered the very cool nn, Baz. It's almost too good to pass up. So as a fn, I'd suggest Basil. As a mn, I'd suggest Arthur since it flows so well with many names.
vote up1
Arthur!I really like Arthur and have never really gotten the appeal of Basil. I work at a daycare, and we have two kids in our infant room named Arthur and Iris, and it always reminds me of that song "Arthur, lives next door to Iris..." from The Holiday. Sorry, that got a bit off-topic.
vote up1
ArthurLove Arthur. Basil is meh.
vote up1
Arthur+Though Basile is good too.
vote up1
Basil.:)
vote up1
Arthur!
vote up1
Arthur...Arthur over Basil any day
vote up1
Arthur...
vote up1
ArthurNot super fussed on either of them, but Arthur has charm.And while Basil is awesome in theory, it's seems like it'd be hard to pull off as a first name.
vote up1
I'll go with Basil on this one. Not a fave, but not a hate and I prefer it ot Arthur.
vote up1
Arthur
vote up1
Arthur
vote up1
BASIL!!!!I love the name Basil soooooooo much. And I secretly adore the nn Baz. I like Arthur too, but I can't stand the nn Art or worse, Artie. Basil just sounds so hip and cool. It's not a name you hear every day, and when you do hear it, you stop and appreciate it. Or rather, I do.
vote up1