View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

[Opinions] I think you're on the wrong board.
You might want to try a baby name board, not a board dedicated to etymology.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Now wait a minute. This post is on the Opinions board, not the name facts board. The huge majority of the posts on the Opinions board deal with people's feelings about baby names. If you don't care for this person's choices, express your opinion, but there is no reason to tell her she's not welcome to ask for opinions. Perhaps the opinions of people who are interested in etymology are what she's looking for.
vote up1
Agree, she shouldn't have been told to go away.
ChrisellAll we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us. - J.R.R. Tolkien.
vote up1
OT questionDo you happen to know when people started using surnames as first names? I've read somewhere that it started in Scotland in the 17th century, but I don't know how accurate that is. :) Thanks.
vote up1
As I understand it, this began among the gentry in England during Elizabethan times, though it was very rare in the beginning, and was the names used were normally the surnames of close relatives (often the mother's maiden name) or godparents. One of the earliest examples is Lady Douglas Sheffied, who was born in 1545. Her existence is sort of doubly ironic because she was a woman, and because Douglas is still almost exclusively a male name when used as a given name in English speaking countries today:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lady_Douglas_SheffieldThe custom grew greatly during the early 19th century in the USA, when it became common for boys to be given the surnames of famous men as their given names, whether or not there was any family connection. In spite of Douglas Sheffield, it was always much rarer for girls to be given surnames as first names than boys, though this was much more common in the Southern USA than elsewhere before modern times. During the last few decades, it seems as if many modern parents make little distinction between former surnames and other given names in all English speaking countries, and the girls are catching up to the boys, with many recent fashionable surname forms such as Delaney and Presley becoming common for girls without ever having gone through a previous period of noticeable use for boys, like Shirley and Ashley did.
vote up1
Thank you very much. That's all really interesting. :)
vote up1
No kidding!
vote up1