View Message

grotesque! no, seriously, not trolling - this is seriously, seriously gross. why would you do that to a person - an animal - a...thing?! argh.

I actually like it on a girl. I think it sounds more feminine than masculine. I didn't even know there was a Carlisle in Twilight (I've managed to stay away from all things Twilight), so for me it's not a problem.

I really like it -- stuffy surnames are among my guilty pleasures.

It's a huge GP of mine. I've never read or seen Twilight so only know about Edward, Jacob and Bella.
I've loved it since I discovered the Scottish actor Robert Carlyle and this is my preferred spelling.

Twilight, but not too much.
That said, I'm a twilight nerd. Yeah, really. So I obviously think of Twilight when I see/hear Carlisle.

Dang, is it Twilight? I'm part of a very small minority who knows not a thing about Twilight. But I think Carlisle is awesome. A smidge nerdy, but there's nothing wrong with nerdy.

I think of the City of Carlisle before I think of Twilight. I'm pretty indifferent to it, I've never met anyone with this name though I would struggle to see it on a child.

---

Way too Twilight and nms anyway.

---

Funny story, when my quasi-little brother (my actual little brother's friend who is with my family more than his) was reading the Twilight books he always read that name as car-lizzle. When he told me that, I almost died laughing. Those books are so mopey and serious but if someone was named by Snoop Dogg, that would have been hilarious.

I like Carlisle and would be pleased to meet a little boy with this name. I wasn't aware of the Twilight association, but I haven't read any of the books or seen any of the movies.