View Message

[Opinions] Modesty
Do you think it works as a name? Modesty is a character on 'Fantastic Beasts'. I interpret the meaning more towards someone being humble than modesty as in dressing modestly. Opinions?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

SexThe problem with a name like Modesty is that it can be interpreted in many ways, some of which are sexual or anti-feminist. Its like the name Chastity. I've never understood the appeal.
vote up1
No clue about the Fantastic Beasts character; the one I always think of was a character in a UK newspaper strip comic who was a sort of female James Bond without the technology. She was drawn wearing the most mini of skirts, alarmingly plunging necklines, high heels and a bun which stayed in position - occasionally becoming a tiny bit unravelled round the edges - even while she was knocking out bad guys with spectacular kicks! Modesty Blaise was her name, espionage and mayhem was her game and, to make matters worse, she had an adoring but always platonic male sidekick (pun intended) whose name was actually Willy.I wouldn't use it.
vote up1
In the category of virtue names, I'd rate it somewhere between Chastity (which I hate) and Prudence (which I kind of like).I just know I wouldn't want to be named that; if I was, I'd either use my middle name instead or tell people to call me Maud.
vote up1
English virtue-word names can't help but remind me of their opposites. This makes them seem sort of anxious and droll to me.
Modesty ... lest you be vain or proud.
Chastity ... lest you be lustful.
Temperance ... lest you be gluttonous.
etc.
So that is why they don't appeal to me as names (at least not the ones that are most easily related to character and actions).
They're not totally awful - they seem ordinary enough. But they're nms.If I think only of the sound of "Modesty," it doesn't have a lot of appeal to me either, but it's not bad. I don't really like the sound of the -esty ending. I'd prefer the word Modest as a name, considering only sound.
vote up1
I think they were purposely trying to use in-your-face, creepy Puritan names. That's the only way I could think of it if I saw it IRL.

This message was edited 12/4/2016, 8:32 AM

vote up1
Yeah I agree, Credence is sort of creepy like that too! (Is that even how you spell it idk)
vote up1
No thank you.
I have no problem with modesty either as interpreted as humbleness or as dressing modestly (you can dress modestly and still be very stylish) but the sound itself is ugly, and the proper-nouning of it sounds like a brand name. Like an adult diaper or an undergarment for the obese or something to hold in hernias.
vote up1
You're right about the brand name. I believe there are catheter brands with this name, and feminine hygiene products.
vote up1
I don't know if they still have them ...But there used to be a line of sanitary pads called Modess. I think it might have been pronounced Mode-ESS, but I can't be sure.
vote up1
It works as a name in a way, in that it is an attractive word, but the meaning.....I suppose some would consider the meaning wholly positive, but is modesty always a good trait? Can't one be overly modest? To the point of prudishness or lack of self-esteem? For that reason, I say no.
vote up1
I wonder if Modesty as a concept might mean - the appropriate level of restraint in those matters? I like to think of it that way, because I think it's an important idea - one not very well understood in our culture. But I understand it's not really received that way.
vote up1
One of the less beautiful virtue names, dislike the gloomy mo-sounding.
In the sense of one can take, but one does not have.
But still far better than Chastity, Charity or Serendipity.
vote up1
I dislike most virtue names, including Modesty. I dislike the meaning, the look, the sound, the character in 'Fantastic Beasts'. There are better options out there.
vote up1