View Message

[Opinions] Venus or Aphrodite?
If you had to give one to a daughter, which one and why?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Venus. It seems more usable.
vote up1
Aphrodite, just because I have visited her mythological "birthplace".
vote up1
Venus, because there are multiple connotations for it, and probably less obnoxiously correlated to the Roman God than Aphrodite is to her Greek counterpart.
vote up1
Venus! It's shorter, easier to spell, has more of an association with astronomy than the myth, and it's the setting for one of my favorite books-- Perelandra by C. S. Lewis.
vote up1
Aphrodite, because I have better associations with the sound of it...Venus makes me think of "venal" which reminds me of "venereal" (disease).Aphrodite makes me think of afros which reminds me of funky fashion styles and music; also, there's a female character in the Darth Vader comics called (Dr.) Aphra, and I'm enough of a Star Wars geek to see that as a positive.
vote up1
Can I say: Neither? I find naming your daughter aftr a goddess of love, rather pretensious, personally. What if she's not drop dead gorgeous? But IF I was forced to pick one or the other: Venus, more planet like and not quite so loaded as Aphrodite.
vote up1
Often the point of these either/or questions is to make you pick the lesser of two evils. It's fun that way. I'd never name a daughter either name myself. If I had to choose, I'd pick Aphrodite. I don't like it, but to me Venus is more of a term for a very beautiful woman than Aphrodite is, so Aphrodite would be less embarrassing.
vote up1
Venus, because it's prettier. Aphrodite just makes me think of "hermaphrodite".
vote up1
It'd have to be Venus, I'm afraid, though I dislike both of them.Aphrodite is too long to go unshortened, and it shortens to Aphro, like a wrong spelling of an old hairstyle.Venus, apart from its tennis associations, was also the name of a very elderly lady I once knew; she was tiny and plain and had never married, but she ruled the local Scrabble club with an iron hand. So at least it happens IRL.
vote up1
Despite the rhyme, I would use Venus for the astronomy touch over the more obvious goddess one.
vote up1
Venus. It's way more goddessy to me, and not so associated with aphrodisia.Also, it doesn't rhyme with penis, just as thus isn't this.

This message was edited 10/1/2017, 10:35 PM

vote up1
nevermind

This message was edited 10/2/2017, 9:32 AM

vote up1
Venus. Hate the Afro- beginning sound.
vote up1
Venus, even though it rhymes with penis. Aphrodite is too much name, for me.
vote up1
I'm honestly not sure. Aphrodite seems a little up-its-own if you know what I mean, and Venus has such an unfortunate, easy rhyme.I guess Aphrodite.
vote up1
Venus, it reminds me more of the planet and isn't so much connected with beauty/looks.
vote up1
Aphrodite, I prefer Athena to Minerva and Zeus to JUpiter also. It reminds me more of the goddess and less of the planet.
vote up1