View Message

[Opinions] Tallow
This has just become a GP of mine for a boy. I wouldn't use it as it's too close to Willow, my top girls' name. WDYT of it? Does it change your mind at all to know that Tallowood is a common tree where I live so it has that association rather than just being a made-up name?

This message was edited 2/1/2019, 6:32 PM

Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I think this is the fat you use for candles.
vote up1
It has a nice ring to it, but it’s just another word for fat.
vote up1
all i can think of is Taillow, the swallow pokémon. sorry
vote up1
Males me think of Taillow, one of the bird Pokemon.
vote up1
If you have a personal association with it, by all means use the name if you like it. My opinion should't change how you think of the name. I don't think it personally sounds like Willow that much.
vote up1
Can't even imagine it on a fictional character without snickering. I just think of fat. And I don't think the sound is that great either.
vote up1
It’s not a made up name. It comes from the word Tallow, which is essentially fat. I can’t imagine a more humiliating name I feel I ended up having trouble with my weight.
vote up1
or had pale, oily skin, or stunk.
vote up1
Not really a fan. Makes me think of candles and fat. The sound is nice though, but it's hard to get over the connotations I have for it.
vote up1
Nobody with access to a dictionary would use it anyway.
vote up1
Oh, I don't know. I once knew a young woman named Ferrell. Pronounced just like the word "feral". That's worse than "tallow".
vote up1
No. I'm sure at least one person has already pointed this out, but tallow is "the white nearly tasteless solid rendered fat of cattle and sheep used chiefly in soap, candles, and lubricants". So no. The tree doesn't counteract that.
vote up1
It reminds me of Fallow, which I once made a poll about: https://www.behindthename.com/polls/208508I wonder which one of the two people would like best. I like each of them equally, though Fallow is perhaps an itty little bit more effortless to pronounce.
vote up1
I don't consider words names made up, if they're spelled correctly. That said, Tallow isn't a great one imo, because a word having a pleasant enough sound doesn't outweigh the reality of the word's definition...it's like naming your kid Fat because you like the sound.It'd change my mind a little if the person using it had some reason to regard tallow trees as significant, but that doesn't seem likely.

This message was edited 2/1/2019, 11:36 PM

vote up1
I like the name.
I know a Tallow (born 2001), hes the typical Australian surfer kid, long wavey blonde hair, who pissed off all the teachers at school.
Thats all I think of.
Very usable imo.
vote up1
I had the "fat/candles" reaction at first as well. I could see it as either a fantasy or low-class medieval character.
vote up1
While I do enjoy the imagery/ambiance of candles, the word, “tallow” does not, for me, feel pleasant or appropriate as a person’s name. Meaning aside, I don’t mind the actual sound, but don’t love it, either. I’m sorry to say the tree isn’t any help where the “tallow” spelling is concerned and, to be honest, that connection feels counterintuitive as the tree really isn’t “tallow-ood”, but a “tallo-wood”. Maybe this is just me and my personal brand of OCD, but I would hypothetically imagine a person named after a Tallowood tree to be either Tallo or Woody. Of course, the sound of Tallo would still likely be associated with tallow.
vote up1
The trees are tallow, not tallo, although tallo is Spanish for stem, so there's that if someone wanted a plant association.
vote up1
Ah, thanks for straightening me out on the tree name; guess those who chose it didn’t care for the double “w” in the spelling. Misleading, but understandable. ;)
vote up1
vote up1
I like it, but it feels more feminine than masculine. The tree associations just make me like it even more.
vote up1
I kinda of like it but in a GP sort of way. A name I wouldn't mind coming across in a book (being used in theory I suppose you could say) as opposed to real life.
Willow is endearing.
vote up1
It sounds interesting but I just think of fat/candles/lanterns.
vote up1
Like the others said, tallow is animal fat. The tree doesn't make it a viable name.
vote up1
not to close to Willow ...Too close to beef fat.
I'm amazed that this is not the first time this "name" has been mentioned on this board.
I think it's really, really stupid, and ugly. Doesn't change anything that there's a tallowwood tree; we have dogwood trees here and that doesn't mean it's okay to name your kid Dog.
vote up1
I associate it with rendered beef fat. Not a great association for a name. It's like name your child Lard. It also rhymes with sallow. Tally is a cute nickname, but it is about the ok nly redeeming quality imo.
vote up1
Tally isn't even that great a nn. Mark your tally. Tally up the scores. Tally-ho.
vote up1