[Opinions] Re: Judy
in reply to a message by Martha
I love both Judith and Judy. I think of the White Christmas character, and I love the way they feel as I say them. This name spent a long time in the top spot on my list.
The only thing that holds me back from actually using it is that I go back and forth about its appropriateness. I know non-Jewish people have used it for a long time and that it’s moved beyond its original meaning for most people. But I study names and their origins. I can’t plead ignorance or claim that meanings suddenly don’t matter.
I guess what I’d like to see is for lots and lots of people who aren’t me to start using it again. People who don’t have my hang-ups and who can just enjoy it.
Patty is not a favourite. While Judy feels ripe for a comeback, Patty still feels dated somehow. Plus it reminds me of the disc-like food shape. Hamburger patty, peppermint patty, etc. I could see Judith with
Alexandra (Judy and Sandy)
Beatrix (Judy and Trixie)
Eleanor (Judy and Nora)
Evelyn (Judy and Evie)
Lydia (Judy and Lydie)
Margaret (Judy and Peggy)
Penelope (Judy and Penny)
Rosemary (Judy and Rosie)
Verbena (Judy and Beanie)
The only thing that holds me back from actually using it is that I go back and forth about its appropriateness. I know non-Jewish people have used it for a long time and that it’s moved beyond its original meaning for most people. But I study names and their origins. I can’t plead ignorance or claim that meanings suddenly don’t matter.
I guess what I’d like to see is for lots and lots of people who aren’t me to start using it again. People who don’t have my hang-ups and who can just enjoy it.
Patty is not a favourite. While Judy feels ripe for a comeback, Patty still feels dated somehow. Plus it reminds me of the disc-like food shape. Hamburger patty, peppermint patty, etc. I could see Judith with
Alexandra (Judy and Sandy)
Beatrix (Judy and Trixie)
Eleanor (Judy and Nora)
Evelyn (Judy and Evie)
Lydia (Judy and Lydie)
Margaret (Judy and Peggy)
Penelope (Judy and Penny)
Rosemary (Judy and Rosie)
Verbena (Judy and Beanie)
This message was edited 1/9/2022, 4:22 AM