View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

[Opinions] DIETER!
Excellent!Yeah my professor is saying a lot of names really differently from how I expected it (idk why BTN lists it as 'old german') I am getting over my freaked-out overwhelmedness enough to notice that R's are l's and ch is sh. It was very alarming to hear a German speaker say Friederich Wilhelm. Fleedeleesh Villlem.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Honestly, as a German speaking person, I don't know where someone would get that weird pronounciation from. R's are R's over here as well and never L's. As for the Ch: It's difficult to explain how it is said, but it's no Sh.
But I guess wikipedia might explain it better than me.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_language#Phonology
vote up1
Yup.I live in a German area and my boyfriend speaks a smidgen or two of German. Rs are Rs - German is a very harsh language.
vote up1
That's what I thought!I was staring at that pronunciation thinking, "Woah, that L's not right!" but I'm just a first-year German student, and I don't know about an 'old German'.
vote up1
HmmmI have been saying R further and further back in my mouth all today and eventually it sounds a lot like LMy teacher is a native German, I dunno where he's from in Germany, so I dunno if it's dialectal or something. But it is definitely an R that could be confused with an L. I have been listening intently and he has definitely been saying something that sounds like an L. Probably super-guttural R. I remember paying extra special attention when he said Diederich and thinking "Oh man that is funny because it has Deedle in it why does it have deedle"So I dunno! I am going to listen to him very hard.
vote up1