I love Woods almost more (giving credit to Ludvig/beethoven/[Emma] for that)! And you nailed both right on the head: fresh vs dusty. But I also love that juxtaposition and the OPTION for both.
I'm certainly not opposed to just Woods, though :)
Woodrow Elias is really nice, a good mix.
Woodrow Clement has a great air about it, but I feel like it reads too long.
Woodrow Martin has a great ring too, but feels to me like a Fn/LN combo. Uuuugh, this is why it's so hard for me!