this is an opinions board, and people give their opinions. As long as they answer your original question, I don't see the problem in other additions to what you asked. Orchid replied what she thought of Marielle under your post. So what that she gave another suggestion. If you liked the suggestion you would have thanked her!
(I read many posts where people ask for opinion on combos, then another poster gives other suggestions (un-asked for), and then the original poster replies with: Oh my Gosh! I love that suggestion!)