View Message

[Opinions] Funny mispronounciation of Madison
I was at the YMCA and a non-native English speaker was asking another mom what her daughter's name was. The daughter's name was Madison but the other mom thought she was saying "Medicine" and was asking why she would name her child that. It was pretty funny for me, but Madison's mom was pretty upset. I never realized that Madison sounds like medicine! Yet another argument against the name.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Speaking of MadisonI met my first male Madison today! He's in high school. Now I'm happy. :-)
vote up1
I had an Australian professor whom I talked with about Madison (a school) and he kept saying 'medicine', which took me a second to figure out.All things considered, Madison is so lovely. I have a relative named Maddison. Fan of the name, not the spelling.
vote up1
My teacher does that....There used to be a girl named Madisen (spelled like that) in my math class. My teacher, who has a german accent, would always say medicine.
vote up1
I think it some accents the 'a' and 'e' are less distinct. They're very distinct in mine. I know that in some places Keren would sound the same as Karen. Am I think of Oz / New Zealand perhaps? These vowel differences are so subtle I can easily see how they'd be confused by a non-native speaker, though. I'm surprised Madison's mother took it personally - I wonder how many foreign languages *she* tries to speak, but that's a different rant...
vote up1
I can definitely see what you're getting at with the vowel sounds... but it's not an oz/nz thing. I'm from NZ and Keren and Karen sound totally different, as well as Madison and Medicine...
vote up1
Keren sounds totally different from how we (Kiwis) say Karen, but very similar to pronunciations of Karen that I've heard from US English speakers. I've never heard Madison pronounced like anything approaching Medicine, but then my perception of Kiwi vowels is probably different to a US english speaker (the other night at work I gave some American customers some feedback forms and they looked at me blankly - I had to say feedback a couple more times before it made sense to them lol). I can imagine someone with a very strong South African accent pronouncing Madison that way.

This message was edited 3/1/2008, 2:52 PM

vote up1
They sounds the same in the U.S., as far as I've experienceBut it's not because of an a sound so much as the fact that there is not an actual a-sound in the American pronunciation of Karen. Mad- and med- sound totally different to me.
vote up1