View Message

Ugh to both. I'd say Paige is better, though, because I think my dislike of it is just due to knowing a really bratty Paige when I was a kid. Brooke's probably more popular here, and it sounds trashy to me.

---

Paige Louise - there's something strangely matchy about it, and I can't place it
Paige Elizabeth Louise is alright.
Paige Elsa has weird flow to me.
Paige Noelle is pretty good.
Paige Annabelle - I think the short and cute quality of Paige contrasts badly against the extravagant elegance of Annabelle. Noelle has elegance, but it's simple enough that they don't clash, they just balance.

---

Brooke Annabelle is the best of the Brooke combos, imo.

I'd pick Brooke. I think it's a great name!

---

Paige Elsa Louise & Brooke Eloisa are gorgeous combos!

aw Paige Louise

---

I don't particularly like how it looks, but it sounds reeeeaally cute. Especially as a double name.

---

I've known both one Brooke and one Paige, so I'd say they are pretty equal in popularity where I live.

---

If you like Marie, Marie Paige would be pretty dang adorable too.

I used to like the sound of Paige until I really focused on its meaning and didn't care for it. I mean, I realize Brooke (brook) is a noun and a nature reference, however, it's picturesque and tranquil and has a lovely sound and represents all of these good associations to me so I'd go with that. Of your combos, I like Brooke Estella best, however, I'd recommend Brooke Louise Elisabeth to incorporate Louise and Elsa or even Elsa "Brooke" Louise although I know some people don't like going by the mn.

I'd go with Brooke, hands down. Paige is okay, but i know several (all born between 1994-1996), it seems a bit dated to me. I do like Page as a middle name for a boy though.

---

I know one Brooke, she's 2 or 3 I can't remember and I know of no other's, it's really not common here.

---

I'd choose Brooke Annabelle

---

The Brooke I know is Brooke Marie

I prefer Paige. It sounds crisper and more interesting to me than Brooke. Brooke is more popular where I live than Paige (but Brooke has been completely eclipsed in local popularity by the gagworthy Brooklyn).

---

Paige Louise: (5) I've grown to love Louise, but I'm still underwhelmed by it as a MN.
Paige Louise Elizabeth: (5)
Paige Elizabeth Louise: (5) This is the one I'd pick if I had to use one.
Paige Elsa Louise: (4)
Paige Elsa: (5)
Paige Noelle: (5) This would be my second pick.
Paige Annabelle: (0) "page an' a bell"

---

Brooke Annabelle: (1) "brook an' a bell" I'll give it a 1 because it doesn't leap out at me quite the way Paige Annabel does.
Brooke Estella: (8) This is my favorite combo listed. It makes me picture the Milky Way, or a river of stars.
Brooke Marie: (4)
Brooke Eloisa: (6)
Brooke Aquinnah: (6/7) This is interesting. I like it.

---

Overall, I prefer your Brooke combos.

Brooke. No contest.

---

Brooke Louise or Brooke Estella could work.

Paige Annabelle.

---

nz

I'd go for Paige any time, because where I live, Brooke sounds like the word for trousers and underpants.

---

Paige Louise is really distinguished. Paige Elizabeth Louise would get your Elsa variant in very neatly. And what about Paige Marie?