I would probably use Nutmeg as a MN (ok, I wouldn't actually use it at all, but theoretically), but I think I could come up with a few Nutmeg-as-a-FN combos.
Nutmeg
Margaret (Hee hee, I had to. Meg-Meg for short?)
Nutmeg
LucilleNutmeg
OliviaNutmeg
ThereseNutmeg
SylviaNutmeg
VictoriaNutmeg
Susanna
I think I like it paired best with a classic MN.
Nutmeg as a MN:
Julia Nutmeg
Henrietta Nutmeg
Clara Nutmeg
Georgina Nutmeg
Yes, it definitely pairs best with classic, vintage names. Nutmeg just gives me that feel.