View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

[Opinions] Re: Rosalind
I don't know what's "correct", but I say it with the o as in lock, and the s sound is like a z.
(The only reason I didn't say O like in Ross is because I think my New Jersey accent has me saying Ross differently than most people in the U.S.)
--"We are all horrible and wonderful and figuring it out." - Harris Wittels
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Me too!
vote up1
Me too. It has to be a short O because it doesn't mean Rose the flower. That Ros in Germanic languages means and is I suppose the same word as Horse, and if I once discover an etymology it never deserts me.
vote up1
Well as far as I know, Rosamund is said with a long o. I'm not sure that differentiation from the word Rose means it can't be pronounced the same way.
vote up1
Yeah, because it actually is Ros- = Rose, not Ros- = Horse! Either Rosa munda = elegant rose or Rosa mundi = Rose of the world, depending on one's opinion of King Henry II's alleged girlfriend, said to have been terminated with extreme prejudice by Eleanor of Aquitaine but in fact a later legend. Either way, it's Latin, not Germanic.And, surely, one pronounces Rosa with a long o?
vote up1
According to the database the Ros- in Rosamund also comes from hros. But I would guess that with both Rosalind and Rosamund, they were influenced by "rosey" meanings, spellings, and probably pronunciations. Rosalinda, for instance, is pronounced RO-sa-linda, and it's not incorrect - especially because it also means "pretty rose" in Spanish. This database even has Rosalind pronounced with a long O from that influence.Basically, I was just trying to say that past etymology of an old language doesn't necessarily dictate current pronunciation in modern languages.
vote up1
Not according to the database entry on Rosamund. It is Germanic and it originally meant horse evidently.

This message was edited 7/21/2016, 11:19 AM

vote up1
No, Rosamund and Rosalind are both with a short o, at least in the UK. Maybe it's different in America?
vote up1
Not to me.
vote up1
I honestly don't know because I've never heard it IRL haha. That's good to know!
vote up1
same
vote up1