I never cared for
Sadie. The "sad" part always jumped at me, even though it isn't pronounced like the word.
I always liked
Sally better.
I still like
Sally better in theory (old fashioned, looks nice, ready for a revival), but after saying both names out loud, I have to admit that
Sadie sounds nicer to me. Which do you prefer?
Do you like
Sally or
Sallie better?
Or would you just stick with good old
Sarah, which both name derive from?