From best to worst:
AngelicaAngeliqueAngelineAngelinaAngelaAngelEvangeline
I find
Angel too abrupt, and
Angela is still too blunt and boring for me.
Angelina is ok, although it's a little too sickly sweet for my current taste.
Angeline is nice but I don't find it spectacular.
Angelique feels dated in a fun way, and it's kind of loud and brassy, so I do enjoy that.
I used to like
Evangeline the most, but now I think it sounds preachy and cruel, so I like it the least. Gives me the shivers.
Angelica is very nice; I like that it's also a botanical word name, and the name of an artist I admired when I was young,
Angelica Kauffmann. I think
Angelica is my favourite for those reasons.