New Post
Search
Help[Opinions] Re: Top 20 from French BA's (Le Figaro)
in reply to a message by Caroline Mae
Yes, I actually really like both Amber and Angelique. I didn't mean anything bad by working class, i.e. not pretty or unrespectable. The case with Amber may be that you are a few years older than me. There is a Steven Levitt (economist) article that, while flawed, included a list of the top 5 girls names given almost exclusively among rich white American parents vs. the top 5 among poor white American parents during the '90s. Amber was #1, I believe, which has backed up my personal observations. The article also mentioned that many of the names currently used among poorer people had been 'introduced' as trends among the wealthy, ten or so years earlier.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1
Replies
Actually I doubt if you are a "few years younger" than Caroline Mae because she is only 16.
I actually don't think Steven Levitt had very good data to show that Amber actually had ever been really popular with upper class American parents. In my reading of the chapter in his book Freakononmics, he jumped to a lot of conclusions about names automatically cycling "down the social scale" without giving enough supporting data. In spite of Caroline Mae's personal experience, I think that on a national basis in the USA Amber has probably always been a bit skewed toward blue collar families, at least since the novel and film Ever Amber back in 1945.
Of course we also must remember that all of Levitt's data on this issue came from California and might not be completely applicable to other parts of the USA.
I actually don't think Steven Levitt had very good data to show that Amber actually had ever been really popular with upper class American parents. In my reading of the chapter in his book Freakononmics, he jumped to a lot of conclusions about names automatically cycling "down the social scale" without giving enough supporting data. In spite of Caroline Mae's personal experience, I think that on a national basis in the USA Amber has probably always been a bit skewed toward blue collar families, at least since the novel and film Ever Amber back in 1945.
Of course we also must remember that all of Levitt's data on this issue came from California and might not be completely applicable to other parts of the USA.
1