I haven't tried an elimination game yet, so I'll give it a go. Take one name from the boys' list and one from the girls' list (give a reason if you can). Have fun! :-)
Boys: Cotton,
Bartholomew,
Cornelius,
Camille,
Claudius,
Florian,
Thaddeus,
Vivian,
Hugo,
Lazarus,
Horatio,
Ira,
Prosper,
Percival, Amasa,
Jocelin,
Benedict
Girls:
Octavia,
Magnolia,
Eulalia,
Rosemarie,
Flora,
Philipa,
Johanna (yo-HAHN-uh),
Beatrix,
Constanza,
Augusta,
Blanche, Tsipporah,
Eustacia,
Bernadette,
Lucia (loo-CHEE-uh),
Annette,
Olive