In the case of
Caitlin, the Irish name spawned two English names.
Kathleen, based on the pronunciation, and
Caitlin, based on the spelling.
Caitlin didn't attain popularity in
America until much later than
Kathleen.
Most Irish names are anglisized based on their pronunciation. But in some cases, there are versions based on their spelling as well. The latter seems to happen after an Irish name has attained a certain level of popularity.
In the case of
Cearbhall,,
Carroll IS based on the pronunciation. (as with
Kathleen, these spellings are appoximations of the Irish, not very exact). If one wanted a named based on the spelling, it would be spelled
Cearbhall pronounced SEER-ball in English.
This message was edited 5/19/2016, 11:38 AM